Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture
Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture
Rainbowed Sea Tours

Photo Tip #13

Choosing strobes for wide angle photography.

orange soft coral

Copyright © 1998 by Chris Newbert

Part 1.

In making a daylight wide angle underwater photograph -- let's use the typical "reef scenic" shot for the purpose of illustration -- the photographer may wish to select certain subject matter relatively close to the lens and provide additional illumination on those subjects by means of an underwater strobe or strobes. This can be termed a "strobe fill" exposure, as the shutter and aperture are set to record the background's ambient light "blue water" value, with the strobes then providing a "balanced" fill light intended to bring out a certain degree of color, detail and tonality that would otherwise not be recorded. Wide angle photography can also be done employing 100% strobe light exposure where no ambient light exists, such as the interior of wrecks, or at night, or even during the day when the selection of shutter speed and aperture is such that the existing ambient light is inadequate to create visible exposure with those settings. Nearly all the criteria for strobe selection for strobe fill or ``combination"  lighting would still apply in this case. The selection of strobes specifically for wide angle work may differ significantly from the selection of strobes for close-up work. Wide angle strobes are larger, more powerful, and significantly more expensive. You will want to consider this investment wisely. The purpose of this two part installment is to examine some of the factors one might wish to consider when choosing the best strobes for wide angle work.

1. While effective wide angle strobe photography can certainly be accomplished with just a single strobe, one strobe for this purpose is very limiting. However, the use of two strobes will a) significantly expand one's creative options; b) will make the reduction or elimination of backscatter easier; c) will allow one to take full advantage of the dramatic "perspective distortion" inherent in all wide angle lenses; d) will allow one to create more even lighting across the broad expanses very wide angle lenses can "see" from relatively short shooting distances. (Don't be mislead by strobe stats claiming extreme beam angles -- say 110 degrees for example -- and erroneously think that such a strobe alone will then provide adequate coverage for your wide angle lens whose angle of view is, say, 95 degrees. It is very unlikely the strobe will illuminate that entire field of view evenly, and it is more likely to provide significantly brighter light in the center than at the edges. Your sea fan will look like it had an automobile headline trained on it when you took your shot -- that dreaded amateurish look. You will not be able to replicate the more natural, softer, "diffused" lighting which two strobes allow.

2. When using two strobes, the strobes should be perfectly matched; that is, identical left and right, same make, same model. Many photographers will have, for example, a big strobe on one side and a small strobe on the other. Such an arrangement will limit their compositions and determine highlight / shadow direction as well as lighting ratios, not to mention the fact that this arrangement won't allow the photographer to create even light across broad areas when desired. The advanced photographer will want to make these decisions for themselves, and not have them dictated by equipment limitations. Different strobes may also have different color temperatures, beam angles, light patterns and recycle times, adding to the complications and disadvantages.

3. Strobes intended for wide angle photography should have wide beam angles. But if wide is good, wider isn't necessarily better. a) As noted above, strobes with beams that are excessively wide may also result in very uneven illumination -- a dramatic hot spot in the center, with unacceptable falloff toward the edges. b) Controlling backscatter is difficult when the beam angles of the strobes are too great. c) Additionally, when a manufacturer uses a reflector which widens the beam excessively, it results in less maximum illumination -- the same number of photons output by the flash tube must now cover a greater area, so the illumination provided at any given point is less. d) My ideal strobe would have a beam angle of around 95 degrees.

4. The more power, the better. You can always reduce power as necessary. But when you need more power and your strobe can't produce it, you're stuck. Small strobes with low maximum output may not produce adequate illumination to provide a balanced fill in bright water at anything but very close distances. The farther away you get from your strobe's subject, the more power you will need to illuminate it. Wide angle photography, by its very nature, is often accomplished at greater distances than close-up photography, and wide angle strobe fill photography will always employ a working aperture based on the ambient light level and chosen shutter speed. Since focal plane shutter cameras (the kind most of us use) have strobe sync speeds generally limited to a 250th of a second or slower, we cannot simply open the aperture up at will the farther away you get to permit a correct strobe exposure, as each wider aperture selection made will necessitate a correspondingly faster shutter speed, and at some point you will run up against the sync speed limit.

I know what you're thinking. You're saying to yourself, gee Chris, that was great, I thirst for more. Well, if you want the rest of the story on wide angle strobes, go to Photo Tip #14 to finish this discussion.

About This Photo

The above photo employs strobe fill lighting, using two Ikelite 200 wide angle strobes. It was taken in the Solomon Islands, with a Subeye Reflex camera, 18mm lens RS lens, and Kodak VS100 film.

Full Seminar Information!

Want to learn while having fun? Sure you do! The only thing that separates you from joining us in some glorious tropical diving paradise and learning the secrets of professional underwater photography is tons of money! But don't let that stop you. Read about my comprehensive Chris Newbert and Birgitte Wilms Underwater Photo Consultation and Slide Show Seminar Series and you too will pilfer your kid's college savings account just to sign up on our very next tour.

Important Copyright Information!

The contents of this page are copyright © by Chris Newbert and my not be reproduced, downloaded, distributed or published in any media in any form, and violation is subject to the full and costly remedies provided by U.S. copyright law.

Individual Questions

If you have a question you would like to see discussed in the Photo Tips section, E-mail me: Chris Newbert. I regret that I cannot personally answer these inquiries, but if particularly interesting questions are presented, I will use them in some future Photo Tips column.

Return to photo tips main page


Home |Hot News |Tours |Newsletter |Contact |
Seminar |Books |Gear |Gallery |Photo Tips

master calendar

Rainbowed Sea Tours, Inc.
74-5590 Luhia Street
Kailua-Kona, HI 96740

Toll Free: (800) 762-6827
FAX: (808) 329-2608
In Hawaii: 326-7752

www.rstours.com

Copyright © 2002 by Chris Newbert and Birgitte Wilms

Picture